Peter Lynch
Lynch first sorts each company into one of six types (slow grower, stalwart, fast grower, cyclical, turnaround or asset play) and then judges it by the tests that matter for that type, such as growth against price for growers, debt and cycle position for cyclicals, and survival for turnarounds. The 0-100 score is the share of that type's points earned, less up to 10 points of penalties, and is held down by caps; the score is only compared with companies of the same type. A company needs to pass the type's checklist, avoid every veto and clear human review items to earn the verdict Lynch would buy.
Rules from One Up on Wall Street. Rubric version 2.1.0.
Numbers only. These scores apply each investor’s published rules to SEC figures and the latest price. The judgements only the filings can settle (management integrity, special situations, the company’s story) come from our AI filings review, which also decides each investor’s Top 100.
Top lists, one per company type
Published once the AI filings review has read each candidate's latest annual report the way Lynch would and a second model has checked the reading. The review is in progress; every company page already shows its Lynch score.
Where the score stands
0 of 5,406 companies have a score.
| Why the others have no score yet | Companies |
|---|---|
| Special-situation review missing No current, cited review confirms the company is free of special situations and unmeasurable liabilities, so it is not scored. | 2,382 |
| Market value not confirmed Market value is missing or does not match price times shares within 1 percent. | 1,179 |
| No financial statements The site has no SEC financial statements for this company, so nothing can be scored. | 769 |
| Not reported in US dollars Statements or the share price are not in US dollars, and the scoring does not convert currencies. | 400 |
| No current share price No usable current share price is available, so no score is shown. | 278 |
| Not an ordinary company stock The security is a fund, trust or similar vehicle rather than an operating company's common stock. | 165 |
| Real estate owner Property companies are not scored because reported earnings misstate their economics. | 143 |
| Industry unknown The company's industry code is missing, so the right tests cannot be chosen. | 49 |
| Statements do not add up The reported debt, cash or equity figures contradict each other, so the company is not scored. | 34 |
| Financial statements out of date The latest annual report ended more than about 15 months before the price date. | 7 |
Six kinds of company
Lynch sorted companies into six types and judged each type by its own checklist; each type gets its own list.
- Asset play
- A company whose cash, hidden assets or free cash flow are worth about half or more of its market value, so you are paying little for the business itself.
- Cyclical
- A company whose profits rise and fall with the business cycle, so timing matters more than the long-run growth rate.
- Fast grower
- A company growing earnings about 16 percent a year or more, with revenue also growing at least 8 percent a year and at most one earnings decline in the measured years.
- Slow grower
- A large, mature company whose earnings grow about 7 percent a year or less (down to about minus 2 percent), valued mostly for its dividend.
- Stalwart
- A big, steady company whose earnings grow roughly 7 to 16 percent a year, bought for dependable gains rather than big leaps.
- Turnaround
- A company that has lost money or whose earnings collapsed, is financially distressed or has a badly beaten-down share price, and is judged on whether it can survive and recover.
The tests
| Test |
|---|
| Asset value |
| Value behind the price Takes the better of two routes: net cash plus any analyst-documented hidden assets as a share of market value (nothing at 20 percent, half at 50 percent, full at 100 percent), or average free cash flow over three years as a share of market value (nothing at 10 percent, 70 percent at 20 percent, full at 35 percent); the hidden-asset part depends on a filings review. Needs the filings review. |
| Not taking on new debt Measures how much total debt has grown over the last two years; full credit if it has not grown, half credit at 25 percent growth, nothing at 50 percent or more. |
| Not issuing shares Measures the growth in diluted share count over two years; full credit at 2 percent or less, nothing at 10 percent or more. |
| Steady earnings while waiting Counts loss years among the last three (an unknown year counts as a loss); none earns full credit, one half credit, two or more nothing. |
| Balance sheet |
| Debt vs equity Takes debt that cash does not cover as a share of that debt plus shareholders' equity; full credit at 10 percent or less, 75 percent at 25 percent, 35 percent at 50 percent, nothing at 80 percent or more. A second route also counts: total debt repayable from average free cash flow in 3 years (75 percent), 5 years (50 percent) or 8 years (nothing); the better route is used, and negative equity earns nothing on the first route. |
| Cyclical debt vs equity A stricter debt share than BS1 for cyclicals with no free-cash-flow alternative; full credit at 10 percent or less, 60 percent at 25 percent, nothing at 50 percent or more. |
| Utility debt vs equity For utilities, the same debt share as BS1 but with an easier scale, since utilities carry more debt; full credit at 45 percent or less, half at 60 percent, nothing at 75 percent or more. |
| Net cash vs market value Divides net cash (cash minus long-term debt, with short-term debt counted where other current assets do not cover it) by the company's market value; nothing if there is no net cash, full credit at 50 percent or more. |
| Cash covers short-term debt Divides cash by debt due within a year; nothing at 0.5 or below, full credit at 1.0 or above or if there is no such debt. |
| Capital spending leaves cash Divides five years of capital spending by five years of operating cash flow; full credit at 30 percent or less, nothing at 80 percent or more, and nothing if operating cash flow was not positive. |
| Growth pays for itself Full credit if free cash flow (operating cash flow minus capital spending) summed over three years is not negative; otherwise credit depends on how many years the cash on hand would last at that burn, nothing at one year, 70 percent at three years. |
| Cash vs all debt Divides cash by total debt; nothing at 25 percent or below, full credit at 100 percent or above or if there is no debt. |
| Cash runway Full credit if the latest twelve months' free cash flow is not negative; otherwise credit depends on how many years the cash on hand would last, nothing at half a year, 40 percent at one year, full credit at two years or more. |
| Inventory not outrunning sales For manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers, subtracts sales growth from inventory growth over the last year; full credit if inventory grew no faster than sales, half credit at 10 points faster, nothing at 20 points faster; not applied to other companies or to those with very little inventory. |
| Cycle position |
| Where earnings sit in the cycle Places trailing earnings within their ten-year range from low to high and checks whether they are turning up; a peak (85 percent of the way up or higher) earns nothing, a low point that is turning up earns full credit, and the middle earns partial credit, with less credit if the upswing is already five years old. |
| Cyclical inventory vs sales Measures inventory growth minus sales growth, as in IN1, for cyclicals; full credit if inventory fell 10 points more than sales, 60 percent if equal, nothing if inventory grew 20 points faster. |
| Capacity discipline Divides the latest year's capital spending by the average of the three years before; full credit at 1.2 times or less, nothing at double or more, a sign of overbuilding. |
| Dividends |
| Dividend paid and never cut Requires the company to pay a dividend now and counts consecutive years back from the latest with a dividend that was not lower than the year before; nothing at zero years, full credit at 15 years. |
| Dividend regularly raised Counts how many of the last ten years the dividend rose by more than 1 percent; nothing at three or fewer, full credit at eight or more. |
| Payout leaves a cushion Divides dividends paid by net income over three years; full credit at 40 percent or less, 60 percent credit at 60 percent, nothing at 90 percent or more, and nothing if there is no dividend or no positive net income. |
| Earnings record |
| No acquisition binge Divides the five-year rise in goodwill (the premium paid in acquisitions) by total assets five years ago; full credit at 10 percent or less, nothing at 50 percent or more. |
| Few down years in earnings Counts, out of the last ten year-to-year changes, how many saw earnings per share fall (an unknown year counts as a fall); no falls earns full credit, one 70 percent, two 40 percent, four or more nothing. |
| Earnings through recessions Looks at how earnings per share held up in fiscal years that fell inside the 2008-2010 and 2020-2021 recessions, compared with the year before; no credit if earnings halved, full credit if they fell 5 percent or less. |
| Growth keeping its pace Compares the recent earnings growth rate with the ten-year earnings trend; full credit if recent growth is at least as fast, half credit if 3 percentage points slower, nothing if 6 points slower or more. |
| Profit margin vs peers Measures the share of similar companies with a lower three-year pretax profit margin (needs at least five peers); no credit at 20 percent, full credit at 80 percent or more. |
| Growth |
| Room to grow tenfold Estimates the profit the company would need for its shares to rise tenfold at a price-to-earnings ratio of 15 and compares it with the 30th-largest profit among companies on this site; full credit when that profit is a tenth of the benchmark or less, nothing when it equals or exceeds the benchmark. |
| Growth in the sweet spot Grades the yearly earnings growth rate: nothing at 10 percent or less, full credit between 20 and 25 percent, 75 percent at 30, 30 percent at 50, and nothing at 100 percent or more, because extreme growth is hard to sustain. |
| Earnings up every quarter Counts how many of the last eight quarters had earnings per share above the same quarter a year earlier; nothing at half, half credit at three-quarters, full credit if every quarter was up. |
| Expansion holding its pace Compares the latest year's revenue growth with the average of the three years before; no credit at one-third of the earlier pace, half credit at two-thirds, full credit if growth is at least as fast. |
| Ownership and insiders |
| Few institutional owners Grades the share of the company held by institutions such as funds; full credit at 0 percent, nothing at 80 percent or more, reflecting the idea that neglected stocks have more room to be discovered. |
| Insiders are buying Counts different company insiders who bought shares in the last year (a lower bound); none earns nothing, one 40 percent, two 70 percent, three or more full credit. |
| Share count shrinking Measures the change in the diluted share count over five years; full credit if it fell 10 percent or more, 40 percent if flat, nothing if it grew 10 percent or more. |
| Price |
| Growth plus yield vs P/E Adds earnings growth rate and dividend yield (in percent) and divides by the price-to-earnings ratio after subtracting net cash; no credit at 0.5 or below, 30 percent at 1.0, 65 percent at 1.5, full credit at 2.0 or above. |
| Growth rate vs P/E Divides the earnings growth rate by the price-to-earnings ratio (after subtracting net cash); no credit at 0.5 or below, half credit at 1.0, full credit at 2.0 or above. |
| P/E vs its own recent past Compares how much the share price rose over the last three and five years with how much earnings per share rose; full credit if the price rose 0.8 times as much as earnings or less, 70 percent at equal, 30 percent at 1.25 times, nothing at 1.6 times or more. |
| P/E vs similar companies Divides the company's price-to-earnings ratio by the median of similar companies (same industry code); full credit at 0.8 or below, 60 percent at 1.0, nothing at 1.3 or above. |
| Price vs ten-year average earnings Divides the share price, less the share backed by net cash, by average earnings per share over ten years (at least eight years known); full credit at 8 or below, 60 percent at 12, nothing at 20 or above, and nothing if the average is not positive. |
| Price vs former earning power Divides the share price, less the share backed by net cash, by the median of the company's positive past earnings per share over up to ten years; full credit at 5 or below, half credit at 10, nothing at 15 or above. |
| Turnaround progress |
| Operating margin turning up Measures the change in trailing operating margin (operating profit as a share of revenue) from a year earlier; nothing for no improvement, full credit at 5 percentage points or more. |
| Sales coming back Divides trailing revenue by revenue a year earlier; nothing at 0.90 or below, full credit at 1.05 or above. |
| Costs being cut Takes the larger of the fall in selling and administrative costs as a share of revenue and the rise in gross margin over the last year; nothing for no improvement, full credit at 3 percentage points or more. |
| Inventories worked down Measures inventory growth minus sales growth for manufacturers, wholesalers and retailers; full credit if inventory fell 15 points more than sales, 30 percent if equal, nothing at 10 points faster. |
| No heavy dilution Measures the change in diluted share count over three years; full credit at 5 percent growth or less, nothing at 30 percent or more. |
Limits
A serious problem caps the score however well the rest goes.
- Price far too high (cap 30)
- Applies to slow growers, stalwarts and fast growers when even the best-case growth-plus-yield to P/E ratio is 0.5 or less. Caps the score at 30 and the verdict is that Lynch would avoid.
- Cannot survive (cap 15)
- Applies when operating cash flow is negative and cash is less than short-term debt plus the year's free cash burn; not applied to financial firms. Caps the score at 15 and the verdict is that Lynch would avoid.
- Growth funded by outsiders (cap 30)
- Applies to non-financial slow growers, stalwarts, fast growers and asset plays when in at least two of the last three years operating cash flow was negative while financing brought cash in. Caps the score at 30 and the verdict is that Lynch would avoid.
- Weak balance sheet (cap 35)
- Applies when equity is zero or negative or debt is 80 percent or more of debt plus equity (85 percent for utilities), unless the company shows average positive free cash flow able to repay the debt within 8 years or, for a turnaround, enough cash against its debt. Caps the score at 35 and the verdict is that Lynch would avoid.
- Cyclical at its peak (cap 45)
- Caps a cyclical's score at 45 when its earnings sit at 85 percent or more of their ten-year range.
- Failed the category checklist (cap 55)
- Caps the score at 55 when the company does not pass the gate conditions for its type.
Deductions
- Balance sheet weakening (up to 3)
- Deducts 3 points for non-financial companies whose long-term debt exceeds cash while cash has fallen and debt has risen over the last year.
- Hottest-stock pattern (up to 5)
- Deducts 5 points when the share price has at least doubled in a year, price-to-sales is 10 or more, and earnings are negative or the P/E is 50 or higher.
- Insiders selling after a run (up to 2)
- Deducts 2 points when the share price has tripled over three years, at least five different insiders sold and none bought.
Our reading of each investor’s published rules, applied mechanically. Not their own words, not their picks, and not a recommendation or investment advice.