Investor scores

Benjamin Graham

Graham looked for safe, boring, fairly priced companies: strong finances, a long record of steady profits and dividends, and a share price that is low compared with earnings and with the assets behind it. The 0-100 score adds up points across seven groups (financial strength, earnings stability, dividends, growth, size, price against earnings, price against assets), subtracts up to 15 points for warning signs, and is then held down by caps when a serious problem or a missing price test is found. Banks and other financial firms get a separate, lower-weighted house score instead of a Graham score.

Rules from The Intelligent Investor and Security Analysis. Rubric version 3.2.0.

Numbers only. These scores apply each investor’s published rules to SEC figures and the latest price. The judgements only the filings can settle (management integrity, special situations, the company’s story) come from our AI filings review, which also decides each investor’s Top 100.

Top 100

Published once the AI filings review has read each candidate's latest annual report the way Graham would and a second model has checked the reading. The review is in progress; every company page already shows its Graham score.

Where the score stands

540 of 5,406 companies have a score.

Why the others have no score yetCompanies
Too little data to score Too many of the tests could not be run (less than 70 percent of the points could be checked, or a key earnings or stability test was unknown), so no score is shown. 1,184
Market value not confirmed The company's total market value is not available, so price-against-assets could not be confirmed. 1,154
No financial statements The site has no SEC financial statements for this company, so nothing can be scored. 769
Earnings record too short Fewer than seven consecutive years of known earnings per share are available, and Graham's tests rely on seven-year averages. 536
Not reported in US dollars Financial statements or the share price are not in US dollars, and the scoring does not convert currencies. 392
No current share price No usable current share price is available, so every price test, and therefore the score, cannot be calculated. 278
Data failed validation The company's financial data failed basic consistency checks (for example figures that cannot add up), so it was rejected rather than scored. 173
Real estate owner Property companies and real estate trusts are not scored because reported earnings misstate their economics. 139
Not an ordinary company stock The security is a fund, trust or similar vehicle rather than an operating company's common stock, which Graham's method does not cover. 125
Industry unknown The company's industry code is missing, so the right tests cannot be chosen. 48
Financial statements out of date The latest annual report ended more than about 15 months before the price date. 7

The tests

TestPoints
Financial strength
Current assets vs current liabilities Divides current assets (cash and other things that should turn into cash within a year) by current liabilities (bills due within a year); no credit at 1.0 or below, half credit at 1.5, full credit at 2.0 or more. 6 (industrial type)
Long-term debt vs working capital Compares long-term debt with working capital (current assets minus current liabilities); full credit when debt is no bigger than working capital, half credit at 1.1 times, nothing at 3 times or more, and nothing if working capital is zero or negative while debt is owed. 6 (industrial type)
Utility debt vs equity For utilities, divides all debt (long-term plus short-term) by shareholders' equity; full credit at 2.0 or below, half credit at about 2.33, nothing at 3.0 or more. 10 (utility)
Interest covered, seven years Checks that profit before interest and tax covered interest payments comfortably over the last seven years, either on average or in the worst year (for an ordinary industrial company at least 7 times on average or 5 times in the worst year; the bar is a little lower for retailers, railroads, airlines and utilities); a company with no interest in all seven years passes, and partial credit is given for an average between 2 times and the bar. 5 (industrial type), 6 (utility)
Conservative capital structure Checks that the common shareholders' own money (book equity after deducting preferred stock and minority interests) is at least half of all capital (debt plus preferred plus minority interests plus common equity), or at least 30 percent for railroads and utilities. 3 (industrial type), 4 (utility)
Earnings stability and profitability
No losses, latest five years Passes if the company reported positive earnings per share in each of the latest five fiscal years. 4
No losses, five years before Passes if the company reported positive earnings per share in each of the five fiscal years before the latest five (years six to ten back). 4
No big earnings drops Compares each of the last ten years' earnings per share with the average of the three years before it; points shrink in proportion to the worst fall found, and a year whose three-year base was zero or negative counts as a complete drop. 4
Return on equity Takes the average return on equity (profit divided by shareholders' equity) over up to ten years, using years with positive equity and requiring at least seven; no credit at 5.5 percent or less, full credit at 10 percent or more. 3
Dividend record
Years of dividends Counts how many fiscal years in a row, back from the latest, the company paid a dividend; full credit at 20 years, proportional below that, and nothing if it currently pays no dividend. 8
Payout or reinvestment pays Gives full credit if either the company paid out at least 60 percent of its ten-year earnings as dividends, or the profits it kept grew earnings by at least 10 percent of the amount retained. 2
Earnings growth
Ten-year earnings growth Compares average earnings per share over the latest three years with the average three years ending ten years earlier; no credit for no growth, about 71 percent credit at a one-third rise, and full credit at doubling. 7
Earnings above four years ago Passes if the latest year's earnings per share are higher than those four years earlier. 3
Size and prominence
Company size Compares annual revenue (for utilities, total assets) with Graham's minimum size, adjusted for inflation since 1972 (about 770 million dollars of revenue, or about 385 million dollars of assets for utilities); credit grows in proportion up to the full amount at the minimum or above. 3
Prominent in its industry Passes if the company's revenue ranks in the top third of companies in the same industry group among those scored on this site. 2
Price against earnings
Earnings yield vs bonds Divides three-year average earnings per share by the share price (the earnings yield) and compares it with the larger of 6.67 percent and the current high-grade corporate bond yield; no credit at 4 percent, about two-thirds credit when it just matches that benchmark, full credit about 4.4 points above it. 12
Price-to-earnings ceilings Passes if the price is no more than 25 times the seven-year average earnings and no more than 20 times the latest twelve months' earnings. 4
Price vs earnings growth Checks whether the price is justified by the company's own recent growth: it compares the price-to-earnings ratio on three-year average earnings with a growth-based fair level (8.5 plus twice the ten-year growth rate, with growth counted at no more than 8 percent a year); full credit when the price is at or below that level, none when it is 4 or more points above. 6
Price against assets
Price vs book value Passes fully if the market value of the company is no more than 1.5 times its common book value (assets minus all claims ahead of the common stock), or if the price-to-earnings ratio multiplied by the price-to-book ratio is no more than 22.5; otherwise credit falls gradually and reaches zero at 45. 8
Price vs tangible book Divides market value by tangible book value (book value minus goodwill and other intangibles); full credit at 1.2 times or less, 75 percent credit at 1.33 times, nothing at 2 times or more. 4
Price vs net current assets Divides market value by net current assets (current assets minus all liabilities and prior claims); full credit at two-thirds or less, half credit at 1.0, nothing at 1.5 or more, and nothing if net current assets or the latest twelve months' earnings are zero or negative. 6 (industrial type)

Graham's checklists

Defensive checklist (Graham)
Graham's checklist for cautious investors: adequate size, current assets at least twice current liabilities, long-term debt no larger than working capital, a dividend in each of the last 20 years, no loss in the last ten years, earnings up by a third over ten years, an earnings yield at least as high as the bond benchmark, and a price low against book value and earnings.
Defensive checklist, ten-year dividend version
A modernized version of the defensive checklist that asks for ten years of dividends instead of twenty; it is shown with its own label and is not counted as a Graham pass.
Enterprising checklist (Graham)
Graham's looser checklist for active investors: price no more than 9 times latest earnings, current assets at least 1.5 times current liabilities, long-term debt no more than 1.1 times working capital, no loss in the last five years, a current dividend, earnings above four years ago, and price below 1.2 times tangible book value.
Net-current-asset bargain (Graham)
Passes when market value is no more than the company's net current assets (current assets minus all liabilities and prior claims) and the latest twelve months' earnings are positive; a stronger label applies when the price is no more than two-thirds of that figure.

Limits

A serious problem caps the score however well the rest goes.

No Graham price test passed (cap 45)
Caps the score at 45 unless the company is shown to pass at least one of Graham's price screens (the defensive price tests, the enterprising price tests, or the net-current-asset bargain test).
No Graham checklist passed (cap 65)
Caps the score at 65 unless the company is shown to pass one of Graham's full checklists (defensive, enterprising or net-current-asset bargain); the modernized ten-year-dividend version does not lift this cap, and financial firms are exempt.
No normal earning power (cap 15)
Caps the score at 15 when average earnings per share over the latest three years is zero or negative.
Speculative price (cap 30)
Caps the score at 30 when the price is 40 or more times the three-year average earnings.
Negative book equity (cap 20)
Caps the score at 20 when shareholders' equity on the latest balance sheet is zero or negative.
Cash burn funded by outsiders (cap 20)
Caps the score at 20 when, in at least two of the last three years, the business consumed cash in operations while raising cash from financing (loans or share sales); not applied to financial firms.
Interest barely covered (cap 25)
Caps the score at 25 when profit before interest and tax covered interest less than 2 times both on the seven-year average and in the worst year; not applied to financial firms, and applied if the check cannot be run because debt or interest figures are missing.

Deductions

Share dilution (up to 6)
Deducts up to 6 points when the diluted share count grew by more than 10 percent over five years, reaching the full deduction at 50 percent growth.
Very low tax paid (up to 3)
Deducts 3 points when in at least four of the last five years the company reported a profit but paid income tax of less than 5 percent of it.
Profit not turning into cash (up to 4)
Deducts 4 points when cash from operations over five years is less than half of reported net income; not applied to financial firms.
Fast-growing liabilities with weak profits (up to 4)
Deducts 4 points when total liabilities are 3 or more times their level five years ago while net income is now zero or negative or less than double its level then; not applied to financial firms.

Our reading of each investor’s published rules, applied mechanically. Not their own words, not their picks, and not a recommendation or investment advice.