Investor scores

Warren Buffett & Charlie Munger

Buffett and Munger look for understandable businesses that earn high returns on the capital they use, turn profits into real cash, carry little debt, treat shareholders well, and can be bought at a price that beats safe government bonds and other choices. The 0-100 score awards points across seven groups (durable economics, returns on capital, cash conversion, financial strength, capital allocation, accounting and pay quality, and price), subtracts up to 8 points for warning signs, and is held down by caps when a serious problem is found. A score of 80 or more is labeled Yes, and only companies that also pass human checks can reach the Top 100.

Rules from Berkshire Hathaway's shareholder letters and meetings, and Poor Charlie's Almanack. Rubric version 2.2.0.

Numbers only. These scores apply each investor’s published rules to SEC figures and the latest price. The judgements only the filings can settle (management integrity, special situations, the company’s story) come from our AI filings review, which also decides each investor’s Top 100.

Top 100

Published once the AI filings review has read each candidate's latest annual report the way Buffett & Munger would and a second model has checked the reading. The review is in progress; every company page already shows its Buffett & Munger score.

Where the score stands

63 of 5,406 companies have a score.

Why the others have no score yetCompanies
Too little data to score A required test could not be run, less than 70 percent of the points could be checked, or a veto could not be checked. 1,483
Market value not confirmed The company's total market value is not available, so the price could not be confirmed. 1,051
No financial statements The site has no SEC financial statements for this company, so nothing can be scored. 769
Bank or lender Banks and lenders are not scored until the data needed to separate common equity from claims ahead of it is available. 464
Record too short Fewer than eight consecutive fiscal years of results, or net income missing in any of the last eight, so the long record the method needs is absent. 458
Not reported in US dollars Statements are not in US dollars, and the scoring does not convert currencies. 345
No current share price No usable current share price is available, so price tests and the score cannot be calculated. 278
Real estate trust Real estate investment trusts and similar pass-through property vehicles are not scored. 165
Not an ordinary company stock The security is a fund, trust or similar vehicle rather than an operating company's common stock. 119
Insurer Insurers are not scored because float, claims reserves and cost of float are not in the data. 105
Industry unknown The company's SEC industry code is missing, so the right method cannot be chosen. 49
Broker-dealer Securities brokers and dealers are not scored because no suitable method exists for them. 35
Share count out of date The cover-page share count is dated after the price date or more than 120 days before it, so market value cannot be trusted. 9
Figures failed the input checks Some of the company's figures did not pass the scorer's consistency checks (for example a total smaller than one of its parts), so no score is shown. 7
Financial statements out of date The latest annual report ended more than about 15 months before the price date. 6

The tests

TestPoints
Durable, predictable economics
Profitable in most years Counts the years in the record (up to ten, at least eight) with zero or negative net income; no loss years earns full credit, one loss 60 percent, two 30 percent, three or more nothing. 5
Steady operating margin Divides the lowest yearly operating margin (operating profit as a share of revenue) by the typical (median) margin; no credit at 0, half credit at 0.5, full credit at 0.8 or more, and nothing if the typical margin is zero or negative. 5
Margin holding up Compares the typical operating margin of the newest half of the record with the oldest half; no credit if it has fallen to half or less, half credit at three-quarters, full credit if it is unchanged or higher, and nothing if the recent margin is a loss. 4
Revenue not shrinking Measures the yearly growth rate of typical revenue between the older and newer halves of the record; no credit at shrinking 4 percent a year or worse, half at flat, full credit at 3 percent a year or better. 4
Returns on tangible capital
Return on tangible capital Takes the typical yearly after-tax operating profit divided by the physical and working capital the business needs (assets minus excess cash, goodwill and intangibles, and non-debt liabilities); no credit at 6 percent, half at 12, 80 percent at 20, full at 25 percent or more. Credit is capped at 80 percent when the tangible capital figure could only be estimated. 8
Average and worst-year returns Half of the credit comes from the average return on tangible capital (nothing at 8 percent, full at 20 percent) and half from the worst year's return (nothing at zero, full at 15 percent). 6
Return on added capital Compares the rise in after-tax operating profit between the start and end of the record with the rise in capital employed; no credit if profit did not rise, half credit at 12 percent, full credit at 25 percent or more. 6
Owner earnings and cash conversion
Owner earnings vs reported profit Compares owner earnings (operating cash flow minus stock-based pay minus capital spending) with reported net income over the whole record; no credit at 30 percent or less, 60 percent credit at 70 percent, full credit at 95 percent or more, and nothing if total net income is not positive. 7
Years of positive owner earnings Counts the share of years in which owner earnings were positive; no credit at 50 percent of years, 60 percent credit at 80 percent, full credit when every year is positive. 3
Working capital not ballooning Checks how much receivables plus inventory minus supplier bills and customer prepayments grew as a share of revenue over the record; full credit if it rose 2 points or less, nothing at a 10-point rise. 2
Financial strength and survival
Net debt vs owner earnings Divides net debt (all debt minus cash) by average yearly owner earnings over five years; full credit with net cash, 70 percent credit at 2 years of earnings, 30 percent at 4, nothing at 6 or more, and nothing if there is net debt but no positive owner earnings. 5
Debt vs operating profit (rails, utilities) For railroads and approved utilities, divides total debt by average operating profit before interest and tax over five years; full credit at 4 times or less, half at 6, nothing at 9 or more. 5
Interest covered Takes the worst year in the last five of operating profit before interest and tax divided by interest paid; no credit at 1.5 times, half credit at 4, full credit at 8 or more (for railroads and utilities half at 3 and full at 6); full credit when there was no interest or debt at all. 4
Short-term debt covered Divides short-term debt (due within a year) by cash plus average owner earnings; full credit at 0.5 or below, nothing at 1.5 or above, and full credit if there is no short-term debt. 3
Capital allocation and per-share value creation
Retained profit earns its keep A rough check that profit kept in the business (after dividends and buybacks) raised earnings per share: the gain in per-share earnings divided by the per-share profit retained; no credit at zero, 60 percent credit when it matches the long-term Treasury yield, full credit eight points above that. 6
Share count shrinking Measures the yearly change in the diluted share count over the record; full credit if it falls 2 percent a year or more, 70 percent if flat, 30 percent at 2 percent a year of dilution, nothing at 5 percent or more. 4
Return including goodwill Takes the typical return over the last three years on capital including goodwill and intangibles, which shows whether past acquisitions were paid for sensibly; no credit at 6 percent, half at 10, full at 15 percent, and not applied when goodwill and intangibles are under 10 percent of capital. 3
Management and accounting-quality proxies
Stock-based pay is modest Divides stock-based compensation by net income plus stock-based compensation; full credit at 5 percent or less, 60 percent credit at 10 percent, nothing at 30 percent or more. 3
Pays real cash taxes Divides income taxes actually paid in cash by pre-tax profit over five years; no credit at 5 percent or less, full credit at 15 percent or more, and not applied when pre-tax profit is not positive. 2
Price against value and alternatives
Expected return, cautious Works out the yearly return an owner would earn at today's price from cautious owner earnings and growth over ten years plus a final value, and compares it with the 30-year Treasury yield; no credit at the Treasury yield, half credit at 2 points above, 80 percent at 4 points, full credit at 6 points or more. 12
Expected return, optimistic The same expected-return calculation using more generous owner earnings and growth; no credit at the 30-year Treasury yield, 60 percent credit at 3 points above, full credit at 6 points above. 4
Beats the best alternative Compares the cautious expected return with the best cautious return among other qualified companies scored in the same run; full credit if this company is at least as good, half credit if 2 points behind, nothing if 4 or more points behind, and not evaluated if fewer than five alternatives qualify. 4

Limits

A serious problem caps the score however well the rest goes.

Loses money over its life (cap 15)
Caps the score at 15 when average net income over the last five years is zero or negative.
Gruesome business (cap 25)
Caps the score at 25 when owner earnings were negative in at least three of the last five years and return on added capital (test B3) earned less than half its points; not applied to utilities.
Leverage that could be fatal (cap 25)
Caps the score at 25 when operating profit covers interest less than 1.5 times on average over the last three years, or net debt exceeds 8 times average owner earnings, or there is net debt with no positive owner earnings and interest cover below 3; for railroads and utilities only the interest-cover part is used.
Integrity concern (cap 10)
Caps the score at 10 when a documented review has flagged the company for evidence of misconduct from a filing; if the integrity review has not been done there is no cap but the company cannot reach the Top 100.
Heavy share issuance (cap 30)
Caps the score at 30 when the diluted share count is at least 1.6 times what it was five years earlier.
Unstable record (cap 40)
Caps the score at 40 and labels the record unstable when any of these holds: net losses in three or more years, net income changing sign three or more times, operating income so erratic that its spread exceeds its average (or the average is not positive), or revenue at or below 60 percent of its earlier peak.
Price is dear (cap 55)
Caps the score at 55 when the cautious expected return is below the 30-year Treasury yield or cannot be calculated because earnings are not positive.
Price is extreme (cap 45)
Caps the score at 45 when even the optimistic expected return is below the 30-year Treasury yield or cannot be calculated.
Price is full (cap 65)
Caps the score at 65 when the cautious expected return is less than 2 points above the 30-year Treasury yield.
Business-quality points below half (cap 50)
Caps the score at 50 when the company earns less than 50 percent of the business-quality points (groups A to F, everything except price).
Business-quality points below two-thirds (cap 65)
Caps the score at 65 when the company earns less than 65 percent of the business-quality points (groups A to F, everything except price).
Returns below a good business (cap 60)
Caps the score at 60 when the typical return on tangible capital is below 12 percent.

Deductions

Payouts funded by debt (up to 3)
Deducts 3 points when five years of dividends plus buybacks exceeded owner earnings and debt rose by more than 25 percent.
Buybacks without a shrinking share count (up to 2)
Deducts 2 points when buybacks were at least a quarter of owner earnings over five years yet the share count did not fall.
Profit growth outruns sales (up to 3)
Deducts 3 points when there were no loss years, earnings per share grew more than 5 points a year faster than revenue per share, and cash conversion (test C1) was below 0.8.
Restatement or weak controls (up to 2)
Deducts 2 points when a documented review finds an accounting restatement or a material weakness in controls; if no review was done there is no deduction but the company cannot reach the Top 100.

Our reading of each investor’s published rules, applied mechanically. Not their own words, not their picks, and not a recommendation or investment advice.