WTI crude oil on April 20, 2020: the day futures went negative
On Monday, April 20, 2020, NYMEX's May 2020 WTI crude oil contract closed at −$37.63 a barrel: sellers paid buyers to take oil off their hands. The June contract, one month further out, closed at $20.43 the same day.
What happened
A WTI futures contract is a promise to deliver or take delivery of 1,000 barrels of crude oil at Cushing, Oklahoma, during the contract month. Anyone still holding the May 2020 contract when it stopped trading on April 21, 2020 would have to take, or make, physical delivery in May.
On Friday, April 17, the May contract closed at $18.27. On Monday it closed at −$37.63, a one-day fall of $55.90 a barrel, while the June contract closed at $20.43. Two contracts for the same oil, one month apart, were $58.06 a barrel apart. Most trading had already moved on: 247,947 May contracts changed hands that day, against 1,319,926 June contracts.
The next day, the May contract's last, it closed at $10.01, and June at $11.57. No other WTI contract month in our price history, which reaches back to the late 1990s, has closed below zero.
The May and June contracts, March to May 2020
WTI crude oil futures: May 2020 and June 2020 contracts
Daily closing prices, dollars per barrel (NYMEX).
The futures curve around April 20
Each line is the whole WTI curve on one day, by months after the front contract. In January 2020 it sloped gently downward (mild backwardation). By April the nearby months had collapsed far below the later ones: a steep contango, the market's way of paying anyone with spare storage to hold oil until later.
WTI crude oil futures curve on five days in 2020
Daily closing prices of each contract month, dollars per barrel.
| Date | Front | +1 month | +2 months | +3 months | +4 months | +5 months | +12 months |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 2, 2020 | $61.18 Feb 2020 | $60.95 Mar 2020 | $60.64 Apr 2020 | $60.24 May 2020 | $59.77 Jun 2020 | $59.25 Jul 2020 | $56.11 Feb 2021 |
| Apr 17, 2020 | $18.27 May 2020 | $25.03 Jun 2020 | $29.42 Jul 2020 | $31.20 Aug 2020 | $32.08 Sep 2020 | $32.71 Oct 2020 | $35.52 May 2021 |
| Apr 20, 2020 | −$37.63 May 2020 | $20.43 Jun 2020 | $26.28 Jul 2020 | $28.51 Aug 2020 | $29.84 Sep 2020 | $30.81 Oct 2020 | $34.68 May 2021 |
| Apr 21, 2020 | $10.01 May 2020 | $11.57 Jun 2020 | $18.69 Jul 2020 | $21.61 Aug 2020 | $23.43 Sep 2020 | $24.73 Oct 2020 | $30.12 May 2021 |
| Jun 1, 2020 | $35.44 Jul 2020 | $35.79 Aug 2020 | $36.17 Sep 2020 | $36.40 Oct 2020 | $36.65 Nov 2020 | $36.90 Dec 2020 | $38.59 Jul 2021 |
Front month minus second month, 2020
The front contract against the next one each day. Deeply negative values mean the nearest oil was far cheaper than oil a month later.
WTI front month minus second month, January to July 2020
Daily closing prices, dollars per barrel.
Why it happened
The CFTC's interim staff report (November 2020) described the background: a global oil market that was already oversupplied at the start of 2020, an unprecedented fall in demand as COVID-19 lockdowns spread, and concerns about whether storage would be available at Cushing, the contract's delivery point. It also noted that liquidity in the May contract had been falling well before April 20. The report did not identify a single root cause.
Our reading of the mechanics, which follows from how the contract is delivered: a holder of the May contract with nowhere to put 1,000 barrels per contract had to sell before trading ended, and with storage looking scarce, buyers demanded to be paid to take the oil. Contracts for later months, which did not require taking delivery that spring, stayed above zero throughout.
What it means for reading a futures curve
- An expiring contract can leave the rest of the curve behind. For this reason our front-month figures move to the next contract two trading days before the last trading day.
- A continuous chart can mislead. A chart that holds each contract until its last day shows −$37.63 as "the price of oil" for one day; the June and later contracts, which held most open positions, never closed below zero.
- Steep contango is a storage signal. When nearby months trade far below later ones, the market is paying for storage. See the WTI curve today and its contango history.
WTI crude oil futures curve · Crude oil COT report · 3-2-1 crack spread · How to read a futures curve
Prices are daily closing prices as delivered by our market data provider; the −$37.63 close matches the settlement the CFTC reports. The charts on this page hold the May contract until its last trading day. Educational information, not investment advice.